← Back to PlanPremise Attack

1 of 1

Premise Attack

Mill: Mill’s Proof of the Greatest Happiness Principle

P1. P1: The only evidence that something is visible is that people see it
P2. P2: By analogy, the only evidence that something is desirable is that people desire it
P3. P3: Everyone desires their own happiness as an end in itself
P4. P4: Each person’s happiness is a good to that person
C. C1: Therefore, individual happiness is desirable. C2: Therefore, general happiness is a good to the totality of people. C3: Therefore, the greatest happiness principle, which maximises general happiness, is a valid moral principle.

Which line is the weakest? Why?

Reveal the answer to continue