← Back to PlanPremise Attack

1 of 3

Premise Attack

Descartes: The Conceivability Argument

P1. I can conceive of my mind/myself existing without my extended physical body existing
P2. Anything that I can clearly and distinctly conceive of is metaphysically possible (since God could 'make it so')
C1. Therefore my mind existing without my extended physical body is metaphysically possible
P3. If it is metaphysically possible for X to exist without Y, then X is not identical to Y
C2. Therefore my mind is not identical with my extended physical body, nor with any part of the physical world

Which line is the weakest? Why?

Reveal the answer to continue