← Back to PlanUnderstanding Phase
1 of 20
Introduction
Does the Existence of Evil Disprove the Existence of God?
- The problem of evil argues that the existence of evil is incompatible with the existence of the God of classical theism, defined as omnipotent, omniscient, and omnibenevolent
- I will consider two versions: the logical problem of evil, which claims God and evil cannot logically coexist, and the evidential problem, which claims that the evil we observe constitutes evidence against God's existence
- Against the logical problem, Plantinga's free will defence largely succeeds. Against the evidential problem, Hick's soul-making theodicy initially appears promising but is ultimately undermined by its own reliance on epistemic distance, which renders it unfalsifiable and therefore evidentially inert
- I will conclude that the existence of evil does not conclusively disprove God's existence, but that the evidential problem succeeds in showing that belief in God is not justified on the evidence available