← Back to Dashboard

Metaphysics of Mind

Paper 2 · Five-Mark Questions · 55 questions across 9 topics

Try 2 questions from this set

Answer each one in your head or on paper first, then open the model answer and compare.

Fundamental Concepts

Explain the following two features of mental states: phenomenal properties and intentional properties. [5]

Show model answer

Phenomenal properties, frequently referred to using the technical philosophical term qualia, concern the subjective, qualitative essence of conscious experience. They capture the private, inner "what it is like" for an individual to undergo a particular experience. Examples include the characteristic qualitative feeling associated with perceiving the colour red, the sharp, raw sensation of pain, or the feeling of intense joy. These phenomenal properties are often characterized as intrinsic and non-intentional, meaning they are qualities inherent to the experience itself and do not necessarily represent or point towards anything external. This private, first-person nature means they are primarily accessible through introspection.

In contrast, intentional properties define a mental state's 'aboutness' or directedness. Intentional states, such as beliefs, desires, hopes, or fears, must, by their very nature, be directed towards some object, event, or state of affairs. For instance, one does not simply have a desire; one desires something, like a specific item, or one believes that a certain proposition is true. This property involves propositional content: the mental state represents a state of the world.

Substance Dualism

Explain substance dualism. [5]

Show model answer

Substance dualism is the view that minds exist and are not identical to bodies or to parts of bodies. Substance dualists think that there are two kinds of substance: (1) physical or material substance, which Descartes called 'res extensa' because its essential attribute is extension in space; and (2) non-physical, immaterial or mental substance, which Descartes called 'res cogitans' because its essential attribute is thought or consciousness. The word 'substance' here is used in its traditional philosophical sense, to refer to a thing that has properties and can exist independently of other things. Substance dualists think that the mind is not merely a property of the body, nor is it reducible to the brain; rather, it is a distinct thing capable of existing independently of the body and of any other physical thing.

What the full set covers

All 55 five-mark questions that can come up on Metaphysics of Mind, each with a model answer.

  • Fundamental Concepts1 question
  • Substance Dualism8 questions
  • Property Dualism9 questions
  • Physicalism: Behaviourism9 questions
  • Physicalism: Mind-Brain Identity6 questions
  • Physicalism: Eliminative Materialism4 questions
  • Functionalism4 questions
  • Issues for Dualism9 questions
  • Similarities & Differences5 questions