Try 2 questions from this set
Answer each one in your head or on paper first, then open the model answer and compare.
The Concept and Nature of God
Explain what it means to say that God is (a) omniscient, (b) omnipotent and (c) omnibenevolent. [5]
Show model answer
To say that God is omniscient is to say that he is all knowing. This could be interpreted as the claim that he knows all true propositions, or as the claim that he knows everything that it is possible to know.
To say that God is omnipotent is to say that he is all powerful. This could be interpreted as the claim that he has the power to do anything, or as the claim that he has the power to do anything that it is logically possible to do.
To say that God is omnibenevolent is to say that he is supremely good - i.e. that he has unlimited or infinite moral goodness. A consequence of his omnibenevolence is that he will never command anything that is morally wrong; this could be understood either as a contingent feature of God (meaning that he could do things that were morally wrong if he chose), or as a necessary feature of him (meaning that he is not capable of doing anything that is morally wrong). Some understand the claim that God is omnibenevolent to mean that he is the source of all moral goodness, like Plato’s Form of the Good. On this account it is impossible for him to do anything that is not morally good.
Ontological Arguments
Explain Anselm's ontological argument. [5]
Show model answer
Anselm defines God as 'that than which nothing greater can be conceived' (the greatest conceivable being). His argument is a reductio ad absurdum: it assumes the opposite of what it wants to prove, and shows that this leads to a contradiction.
Anselm begins by noting that even the fool who says there is no God understands what 'God' means, so God exists at least in the understanding. Then he argues:
1. Assume, for reductio, that the greatest conceivable being exists only in the mind, and not in reality.
2. A being that exists in reality as well as in the mind is greater than one that exists only in the mind.
3. So we could conceive of a being greater than the greatest conceivable being, namely one that also exists in reality.
4. But this is a contradiction: nothing can be greater than the greatest conceivable being.
5. So the greatest conceivable being, God, must exist in reality as well as in the mind.
The argument relies on two key assumptions: that existing in reality is greater than existing only in the mind, and that we have a coherent concept of the greatest conceivable being. In Proslogion 3, Anselm goes further, arguing that God cannot even be conceived not to exist, so God exists necessarily.
What the full set covers
All 38 five-mark questions that can come up on Metaphysics of God, each with a model answer.
- The Concept and Nature of God5 questions
- Ontological Arguments6 questions
- Teleological/Design Arguments7 questions
- Cosmological Arguments10 questions
- The Problem of Evil4 questions
- Religious Language6 questions